Writing Recipes for Instructions
For this post, I am looking at game instructions, deciding what works and what doesn't. The criteria consist of being able to answer these questions:
- Can you tell how many players are necessary to play?
- Can you identify the game goal?
- Do you understand how to win?
- Can you tell what you need to do to get the game started?
- Could you follow how to play the game with other players?
- If the images of the dice and score sheet were not included, would you still know how to play?
- Are the rules clear on the constraints and obstacles that players must overcome?
Instructions should follow these guidelines:
- follow a logical progression, much like a step-by-step, tutorial. Once the game is setup, then the instructions would guide the player on strategies and handling unique situations
- sentences should be written in short, declarative statements that refrain from jargon (they don't use complex sentence structure)
- images are helpful visual guides, but instructions should be understandable without any visuals.
- the main sections are separate and clear - objective, overview, setup, how to play, and how to win (or end of the game).
- use consistent terminology throughout. (avoid something as simple as starting with "you do X" and then later saying "the player does X")
Comparing the instructions of the games Yahtzee (https://www.fgbradleys.com/rules//Yahtzee.pdf) and Lifeboat (https://themindcafe.com.sg/wp-content/uploads/1970/01/Lifeboats.pdf), I found the instructions for Lifeboat to be too jargony and sentences too complex. Yahtzee's instructions, on the other hand, consist of more simple statements in a clear order.
By way of example, I was tasked with writing instructions for something simple- Tic Tac Toe. It was a revealing exercise because, though it is a simple game, writing clear, concise instructions is anything but simple. Here is my current draft of those instructions:
TIC TAC TOE is a game for two players.
objective
The object of the game is to make three marks in a straight line on the grid before your opponent does.
overview
In a grid of nine spaces, players take turns writing an X and an O until one player has three marks in a straight line.
setup
If there is no grid, begin by drawing two vertical lines and two horizontal lines, like a pound sign, to create a grid large enough where nine marks can be made.
how to play
Decide who begins play. Play consists of alternating turns. One player makes the mark X in any one grid space. After they have made the mark, their turn is over. The other player's turn is the same except they make the mark 0.
how to win
Once a player has made three marks in a straight line, they are the winner. If there is a rematch, the winner begins play first.
SkyWren
The prototype I have been working on lately is a game called SkyWren. In my attempt to write instructions for it, there are questions to keep in mind, and here is my first attempt to answer them:
How many players are needed for your game? (does this vary?)
This is a game for one player.
What is the objective (game goal) for your game?
The objective of SkyWren is to encounter enough birds in the forest to pass a quiz in order to gain catch a villain and release kidnapped birds back into the wild.
What is the background information about your game? (setting, characters, history, or other details that give the player a sense of what the game will be about)
You have come to a forest to birdwatch. You have been told this forest is great for birdwatching, that you may encounter some rare birds, and there is a cool treehouse in the center of the forest. But once you arrive, you realize someone is stealing birds and ruining bird habitat in the process. You have to make your way through the forest and find birds to stay on the trail of the villain.
How is the game board or cards set up to play?
There is no setup.
How is the first player selected? (this is incredibly important to establish -- while seasoned gamers will automatically come up with a way if none are presented, novice players will not)
There is only one player, but adding the capability of another player is an interesting idea!
What steps (actions) does the first player take from the start of their round to the end of their round?
There is only one round of play.
What constraints (gameplay rules) are presented as the player goes through their round?
None really, perhaps I need to have the users identify bird calls as they go to advance to the next level.
After the first player, which player goes next? (if more than two players, do you use counter-clockwise or clockwise to determine the order of players?)
N/A
How does the game end?
If all birds are encountered in the game map, then they are taken to the final level where they answer a final quiz to pass.
How does a player win the game? (this is dependent on our 3 C's of gaming - cooperative, collaborative, competitive)
This is a single-player game, so there is no competition with others. They simply finish the course and answer the quiz questions correctly.

Comments
Post a Comment