Evaluating rewards and completion in the mechanics of Oregon Trail

Our class was asked to consider the various mechanics in the classic Oregon Trail game. For my comments, I used the free, fully-functional version on the Visit Oregon site. Below are just a few examples of game mechanics.

Decide when to leave - One of the initial decisions players must make is choosing a date of departure. The trip is difficult and dangerous, taking months to complete. Learning will be facilitated by the mechanic of the wide variety of terrain and resulting seasonal conditions that can result either in success, or illness and death. Leave too early, a long period of the trip will be spent in dangerous heat. Leave too late, the party can encounter life-threatening winter conditions in the mountains. This is a completion achievement in that successful negotiation of the dangers of the trip results in winning the game, and failure results in losing. The reward comes in figuring out the right point in the timeline to leave over successive attempts.

At points along the trip, various parameters can be adjusted. Players can choose to simply proceed at pace with default settings, encountering various landmarks along the way. But for most games, decisions need to be made along the way. Supplies have to last through the more difficult and dangerous parts of the trip- you don’t want to be stuck in the mountains with no extra sets of clothing or enough food, for instance. There are obstacles than can result in loss of inventory and illness. Taking stops to rest can help if health is failing; food rations may need to be adjusted if not enough was taken on the trip.









Fording rivers is one good example of a basic game mechanic that requires some higher order thinking. Players can choose to simply have their oxen walk across or caulk the wagon and float across. Learning will be facilitated by the mechanic of depth and width parameters. If it is too deep but they attempt to walk across anyway, they may lose oxen or supplies. A loss of oxen, damage to the wagon or loss of important supplies can result illness and death. This is a completion achievement in that successful negotiation of the dangers of the trip results in winning the game, and failure results in losing. The reward comes in figuring out how to respond to each of the rivers over successive attempts. Higher order thinking is demonstrated by implementing ideas about how to approach a ford based on the details of the river.


If vital supplies are lost, or wagon parts broken, Attempt to trade becomes an important game mechanic. Multiple attempts at a rest break or a landmark can result in meeting different people and eventually finding someone with whom players can successfully trade. The player meets the "apply" level of Bloom's by applying past experiences to current trade strategy, and applying state of health and supplies to current trade needs. Players meet the "Evaluate" level by weighing loss of party members against survival of the group.




Comments

Popular Posts